The increased human presence dangerously affects the Sage Grouse as well as other mammals to the point of not being able to recover, especially during the winter months. It promised the yearly examination of the drilling effect on the wildlife and it drew a line to establish how much of an effect was too harsh on the animals.
The problem with conservation is our willingness to have a part in it. In the end it would take 18 years to reach full development of its oil fields. It depends on what your moral standards are.
They would have to have the same values and moral standards but obviously they have very different standpoints on the issue. Not drilling in the mesa could be more costly for Americans than creating a plan that monitors wildlife sustainability during drilling in all seasons.
Overall I agree with the fourth option because it went above and beyond just limiting drill pads to a certain number or certain area. In order to drill Questar would have to either halt production during winter months to avoid distressing migratory animals, or invest in new equipment.
Concepts and Cases 7th Edition p par You could attribute the loss of species to both pollution and conservational issues. We know that these are impartial and so is your position on if drilling is a problem with conservation.
What, if anything, should Questar and the other companies be doing differently?
Manmade structures, roads and such could be considered human pollution because it takes away from wildlife and natural resources.
In light of the fact that natural gas reduces the U. From an ethical point of view, was alternative 4 the best option among those from which the BLM chose?
You have a large amount of human pollution when building these large rigs in the middle of the dense wildlife.
How should wildlife species like grouse or deer be valued, and how should that value be balanced against the economic interests of a society or of a company like Questar? Should the loss of species produced by the drilling operations of Questar be considered a problem of pollution or a problem of conservation?
Halting production during winter months would be very costly. Many species could suffer from the increased noise and interference of human intervention in the Pinedale Mesa. If Questar had the same morals and ethics that the conservationist held, hey might stop drilling.
Questar might have also felt a moral obligation to drill because of the massive untapped goldmine of gas found under the sandstone in mesa, and the fact they had the resources to withdraw it. I like number 4 the most because it attended to both sides of the ethical issue.
Questar would have to pack up all machinery and move every year. Is another alternative better from an ethical point of view? What principles or rules would you propose we use to balance the value of wildlife species against economic interests?
Is the cost of losing a bird species worth the creation of more jobs and less foreign dependency? Preserving wildlife over gas companies using cleaner natural gas with less impact on the environment.
Developing new machinery would be very costly but it would half the amount of rigs needed to be set up. Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. What are the systemic, corporate, and individual issues raised in this case?
Not everyone is willing to accept that human interference is a problem with conservation, and some label people who value nature, as extremists.
This shows a moral obligation towards the economy and their buyers. Concepts and Cases 7th Edition p par 4. More essays like this: Creating a pipeline to expedite waste would reduce the human presence overall.CASE STUDY Gas and Grouse Introduction The objective of this case study is to investigate the various systemic, corporate and ethical issues behind Questar.
Essay on Gas or Grouse CASE STUDY Gas and Grouse Introduction The objective of this case study is to investigate the various systemic, corporate and ethical issues behind Questar Corporation’s drilling operations on the Pinedale Mesa. Besides that, this case study is conducted to determine the value of wildlife species and its balance.
CASE STUDY Gas and Grouse Introduction The objective of this case study is to investigate the various systemic, corporate and ethical issues behind Questar Corporation’s drilling operations on the Pinedale Mesa. Gas or Grouse Essay Sample.
1. What are the systemic, corporate, and individual issues raised in this case? Systemic: Buying into the creation of new rigs set up in the mesa means America could reduce its dependency on foreign gas/oil. Gas drilling had threatened the sage-grouse.
What are the systemic, corporate, and individual issues raised in this case?
Question 1 Pinedale Mesa Gas or Grouse? Questar Corporation Sage-grouse Bureau of Land Management(BLM) Sometime called the Pinedale Anticline.
Gas or Grouse Essay. B.
Pages:5 Words This is just a sample. To get a unique essay. Hire Writer. the natural gas drilling has also become very important nowadays. Case: Gas or Grouse? Wood Grouse on a High Promontory Overlooking Canada .Download