The Party is a pain and hatred based society, which results in a distopia. Another difference was that instead of a river surrounding the community there was an edge. More essays like this: Such an idea is named doublethink.
When one analyses The Giver versusit becomes clear that while the societies are meant to be opposites, one perfect and one flawed, the Party and Community are in practice more similar than not, due to the methods used to keep the societies functioning.
Next, we can look at the Community and how it is different from our society.
This is done quite effectively through the use of pills to control hormones. Through the pill and assignment of Birthmother to just a few females, the Community is able to completely abolish sex.
However, one later becomes aware that the two novels are very much related through the ways in which the governments restrain citizens to keep each society intact.
Orwell, however, is not the only author to ponder the possibility of an extreme, futuristic society. The organization teaches children to be on constant watch for disloyalty among their parents. In short, the differing morals that inspire the actions of each government are meant to make the distinction between whether each is a positively or negatively oriented society.
Also in The Cat in the Hat most of the people wear the same color clothes. If I were writing a compare and contrast essay about my sons, I might have this as my thesis statement: The Giver is in principle a utopia, but because of the need to retain control over its citizens is in practice similar to the world of dehumanization and ignorance created by the Party.
Also, food is free and there are transportation systems. One major change is that Fiona was interested in working at the Nurturing Center instead of the House of Old. This demonstrates how methods of maintaining two opposing extreme societies overlap, which raises the idea that no true distopia or utopia can ever really exist.
Clothes were identical in color but some were different designs. All the bicycle, according to what age group they belonged to, were identical.
It could be just because the movie was visual and had a greater effect on everything. In the utopia of The Giver there are still horrific aspects of society, not being able to ever feel love for example.
One thing I want to point out is that the ending of the movie was a lot for adventurous. The movie made reaching the Boundary of Memories more difficult.
It would be cool if all the houses looked the same from at least the outside. My sons are very much alike in their appearance and sense of humor, but they are very different in their personalities, their tastes, and their interests.
Love is one of the key concepts that must be controlled.In particular, The Giver, by Louis Lowry relates a great deal to the themes found in UnlikeLowry's novel focuses on the idea of a utopia as opposed to Orwell's distopia. What is the most interesting is how though the fundamental idea of the novels are opposites, the methods by which each society is maintained are surprisingly similar.
Get an answer for 'How could a student write an essay comparing and contrasting our society to the society in The Giver?' and find homework help for other The Giver questions at eNotes. May 21, · The Giver Compare and Contrast Essay The Giver is about a supposedly perfect society, but as the book progresses it seems to be more of a dystopia with a totalitarian government.
For people life is a routine activity that rarely changes. Comparing and contrasting Jonas from the beginning of the novel until the end of the story Type a well-developed essay comparing and contrasting Jonas from the.
Essay Comparing Brave New World and The Giver - Comparing Brave New World and The Giver When one examines the similarities between Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, and The Giver by Lois Lowry, they may be baffled.
They may think that Lowry just did a. Compare and. Pleasantville vs. The Giver Compare & Contrast In the movie, Pleasantville, and in the book, The Giver, there are many different similarities and differences.
One similarity is that the communities are portrayed as utopias but in reality are actually dystopias.Download